Original school signed only and updates when applicable
| 2007 |
| Trent Appleby |
TCU |
| Austin Anders |
Abilene Christian |
| Evan Blakeley |
University of Evansville |
| Jon Coyne |
El Paso CC |
| Chris Castillo |
McClennan CC |
| Josh Green |
Northern Oklahoma |
| Derek Hamblen |
Belmont University |
| Justin Hall |
Grayson CC |
| Britt Melton |
Paris JC |
| Matt Munday |
Western Texas |
| Andrew Smith |
Texas Tech |
| Tatom Thomas |
Ranger CC |
| Andrew Rehling |
Stephen F. Austin |
| Aaron Rosborough |
McClennan CC |
| Jordan Vaughn |
UTA |
|
Tyler Steed
|
Austin College
|
|
2006
|
| Michael Reed |
Grayson JC |
| Evan Bennett |
Frank Phillips JC |
| Bobby Curtis |
Wayland Baptist |
| Jordan Gomez |
Central Arkansas |
| Brady Hamar |
Northern Oklahoma |
| Eric Lensing |
Hardin Simmons |
| Michael Russo |
Lon Morris |
| Stephen Richards |
University of Arkansas |
| Keith Schulz, Jr. |
Tyler JC |
| 2005 |
| Matt Apfel |
Paris JC / Arkansas-Little Rock |
| Tim Heath |
Paris JC / Texas State |
| Jordan Kratz |
Paris JC / Texas A&M |
| Cody Levins |
Paris JC |
| Jordan Green |
Paris JC |
| Aaron Smith |
TCU |
| Jesse Laster |
Marian College / Paris JC |
| 2004 |
| Jake Arrieta |
Weatherford College /TCU |
| Danny Morris |
Paris JC |
| Sean Rand |
UNLV |
| Travis Spencer |
Grayson CC/ TCU |
| Weston Bina |
Grayson CC |
| Brad Bingham |
Navarro College |
| Bobby Chilton |
Western Texas JC |
| Chris Odom |
San Angelo State University |
| Cory Farra |
Vernon CC |
